Your AI Is Hitting Its Targets. So Why Isn't the Business Improving?

Is your AI improving metrics but failing business outcomes? Discover the hidden pitfalls of measurement in AI implementation.

Article

Imagine introducing an AI agent into a customer service team. The objective seems straightforward: respond to customers faster, reduce the backlog and give people a better experience. The business deploys the system and begins measuring how many enquiries it can handle without human intervention.

A few weeks later, the figures look encouraging. More enquiries are being handled automatically, fewer are reaching employees and the dashboard is heading in the right direction. It looks like a success, except customers are still getting in touch repeatedly because their problems haven't been resolved.

The AI has become better at completing interactions without human assistance, but it hasn't necessarily become better at helping customers. It's a hypothetical example, although it illustrates a problem I think businesses need to understand before giving AI more responsibility.

A system can improve the number we're measuring while making very little difference to the outcome we actually care about. Sometimes, that outcome can even get worse.

## When the score becomes the objective

I came across an interesting example of this in a technical presentation about AI agents competing in machine-learning competitions. In some competitions, participants can see a public score showing how well their model performs against a particular evaluation dataset. It's useful feedback because they can make a change, submit the result and see whether the score improves.

But the final ranking may depend on a separate, unseen dataset. If participants repeatedly optimise against the information they can see, they might become very good at improving that particular score without producing a model that performs equally well on new data. In other words, they can end up fitting the evaluation rather than solving the underlying problem.

The speaker also described an agent that had used an incorrect evaluation approach and mishandled part of the available data, resulting in a misleading performance measure. What interested me wasn't simply that the agent made a mistake. It was that the system continued trying to improve a score when the method used to calculate that score needed checking.

The agent could keep making changes, producing results and reporting progress, but if the measurement itself was flawed, what did that progress actually mean? The system might appear increasingly successful according to its own evaluation while becoming no more effective at the task it was supposed to perform.

This is particularly relevant to business because we rely on measurements to understand whether things are improving. Response times, conversion rates, productivity, production throughput, sales activity and customer satisfaction all help us evaluate performance. There's nothing wrong with measuring these things. The problem begins when a measure becomes a substitute for the outcome it was originally intended to represent.

## A better number isn't always a better business outcome

Consider a sales team using AI to support outbound prospecting. If the system is measured primarily by the number of outreach messages sent, it could increase activity considerably. But if those messages aren't reaching suitable prospects or generating worthwhile opportunities, greater volume doesn't necessarily mean better sales performance.

The same issue can arise in recruitment. An AI tool might reduce the time required to process job applications, which could be useful if hiring decisions remain fair, accurate and appropriate. It becomes less valuable if the business simply makes poor decisions faster.

Or think about management reporting. An AI agent might prepare a report in minutes rather than hours, saving considerable preparation time. But if the figures are unreliable or employees now spend significant time checking the output, the overall benefit may be much smaller than the headline saving suggests.

These aren't arguments against automation. They're reasons to be careful about what we ask automation to achieve. A faster process isn't automatically a better process, particularly if the improvement comes at the expense of accuracy, quality or customer experience.

Return to our customer service example. Is the objective really to handle more enquiries without employees, or is it to resolve customer problems correctly, quickly and with less effort? Those aren't necessarily the same thing.